Friday, 5 May 2023

 So important and yet not known  (Family History)


One is always shy talking about one's own family. But it is lakhs of people who have built this country and that history should be shared. This is why there are many professional agencies now in India that help work on important family histories. 

Recently, on the 5th of April 2023, my uncle Devendra Oza (D.K.Oza) passed away and it was on the occasion of his memorial program, that I revisited my family history. And I realised that this family history is important as public history in shaping India. It covers the life and history of some of the princely states of Gujarat, like Junagadh, Wakaner, Lathi, Lahktar, Vallabhipur. It has history of the independence struggle and some of its Congress leaders, and it has the history of the efforts made by diverse people in building this country post India's Independence. I am grateful that my father Kanaiyalal.K.Oza (K.K.Oza) has penned this history and I share it here with photos.


 

Keshavlal Karsanji Oza, Diwan of the Princely States of Lathi, Lakhtar and Vallabhipur in Gujarat
.Photo: Oza Family Archives


About my Grandparents, Keshavlal Oza (K.K.Oza) and Savitri Oza, my father, Kanaiyalal Oza (also K.K.Oza) says the following:Our Father Keshavlal Karsanji Oza was born in Wakaner in Vikram Samvat 1951 (17th Jan 1895) in the month of Posh. His father Karsanji Pranjeevan was a very religious, honest and simple person. He worked as a primary school teacher. He had from the very beginning joined the Junagadh State’s Education Department. He retired as a primary school teacher with a pension of Rs 40/-." 

 

 

Karsanji Pranjeevan Oza and Dahiben Karsanji Oza (my great grand parents)
Photo: Oza Family Archives

There is little information of our ancestors before him, but I have some idea that my great grandfather Pranjeevan Vishveshwar Andarji Oza was a retail cloth trader in Wakaner. Most of the cloth was sold on credit and this lead to many difficult times when payment failed to come in. As per the information I have, he had to wind up the business with a loss of Rs 1500/-. Karsanjidada took the responsibility of paying up the debt of his father Pranjeevan dada. In return he was given the family house, which was located at the corner of a lane called Oza Sheri (Oza Lane) in Wakaner. As the house was located at the corner of the lane, our family was recognized as ‘Wakaneri Nakavala’.

 

On his 100th Birthday, it would be appropriate to remember and share Bapuji’s (Keshavlal Oza's) life. Though he was born into a simple Brahmin family with economic constraints, he continued his higher education. He completed his B A and also LLB. He was the first person in the whole family to study this far.  

Bapuji told me that on the day he received news of passing matriculation examination in the year 1914, he was taking the family’s only buffalo to drink at the water hole. He took the news in his stride, as if it was nothing extraordinary and resumed his task. To remain calm and composed no matter what was one of the main characteristics of bapuji. We never saw him rejoicing too much with some happy news or saddened with disappointments.

 

Karsanjidada had spent his entire life in the villages of Junagadh State and yet Bapuji started studying BA in Junagadh city’s Bahhuddin College. 


Bahhudin College, Junagadh Photo: Bahhudin College Website.



 After passing BA with honors, he could have got a very good job but he decided to study law. At that time the only law college was in Mumbai and in spite of economic constraint he went to Mumbai. At that time Karsanjidada sold off a small piece of family land for Rs 100/- and helped Bapuji go to Mumbai. However, as Rs 100/- was not sufficient to complete a two-year law degree in Mumbai, Bapuji started giving tuitions to two boys of a Khoja family in Mumbai. By earning like this and some such other work, he completed his law education in the year 1921.

 

It was in the same year that like Karsanjidada, Bapuji too became the disciple of Shri Nathuram Sharma. This tradition continues in our family even now. He also started his law practice in Junagadh the same year. After two years of practice, he decided to be a magistrate in the State of Than-Lakhtar. One wonders why Bapuji left his law practice to be a magistrate. As per bapuji, his average income during the time of his independent practice was Rs 60/- a month. This was a very good income at that time. However as a magistrate his income more than doubled and became Rs 125. It was also prestigious to be a State employee. One may think this to be the reason why he stopped his independent practice. Had he continued to practice law, he could have continued to work for another 60 years at least and would have been one of the top most lawyers in Saurashtra without doubt. 

 

Bapuji worked as the chief magistrate at Lakhtar for 4-5 years but one particular incident bothered him a lot. Bapuji has never put this incident down in writing anywhere. It so happened that the cook of a senior royal member of Lakhtar beat up one man severely. This case came up before Bapuji in the Court. Bapuji was told in private that he should let off the cook. At that time bapuji replied, ‘I will do whatever is possible’. However the evidence against the cook was so clear that he could not be acquitted. Bapuji firmly believed in due justice come what may and sentenced the cook to three months in jail. The result was that the senior royal member stopped speaking with Bapuji altogether. In the evening when all the State employees got together at the club, some members of the royal family refused to acknowledge Bapuji’s greetings (Salam Jeelvi).  Bapuji used to go to the club regularly as he played tennis, but he began to feel uncomfortable to go to the club due to this. At the time of sentencing the cook, Bapuji was aware that a situation like this would develop but stood firm and fearless in delivering justice. The end result was that he had to leave Lakhtar.

 


Lakhtar State Darbar Hall- Photo: Website of Indian Rajputs


Wakaner Palace. Photo: Wikimedia



From Lakhtar he returned to Wakaner and for being jobless, he met the Thakore Saheb of Wakaner. Thakore Saheb of Wakaner was intelligent and sharp and he told Bapuji, ‘Keshavlal it is a pity that you had to leave Lakhtar for having taken a decision that would ultimately be in the interest of the State-what a shame!’ He immediately appointed Bapuji as the treasury officer of the State and told him to continue looking for better opportunities. 

 

During this period, the Thakore Saheb of the small State of Lathi in Gohilwad of Saurashtra and a minor was under administrative training with Wakaner Thakore Saheb. The British Government had appointed Wakaner Thakore Saheb as his Guardian. During his training period, the Lathi Thakore Saheb also spent two months with Bapuji in the treasury department. The British political agent took up the issue of handing over the throne of Lathi to Thakore Saheb once he came of age. As per the tradition, Lathi Thakore Saheb personally was responsible to appoint his Diwan. The chief administrator of Lathi had expressed his wish to resign once the agency administration (British) would come to an end in Lathi on handing over the State to Thakore Saheb. The Lathi Thakore Saheb discussed this matter with The Wakaner Thakore Saheb. And this is what Bapuji told me had happened in his own words:

 

 

' Thakore Saheb was given the responsibility of appointing his own Diwan (Chief Administrator of the State) and I was called personally and asked if I would accept the offer. I clearly refused to accept the offer, as I did not wish to move out of Wakaner. I wished to move ahead in Wakaner itself and requested the post of Chief justice. However Thakore Saheb pressurized me to accept the offer of Lathi Thakor Saheb. Lathi Thakore Saheb ascended the throne at Lathi, got married and I became the Diwan in 1931.'



Though lathi was a small State, it was prosperous and famous. It was famous also because it was the birthplace of the famed poet Kalapi (I believe he wrote one of the first environment - birds protection poems - તે પંખીની ઉપર પથરો ફેંકતા ફેફી દીધો,...લાગ્યા ઘાને વીસરી શકવા કાંઇ સામર્થ્ય ના છે. )

Kalapi, the famous poet of Gujarat (1874-1900), Photo: Wikipedia. 

There were also carriages driven by two horses, fine Arabian horses, police band, etc as in the case of bigger States even in Lathi.  I elaborate on all this because I want to say that all of us brothers and sisters have grown up amidst this magnificence and horse riding, horse races, etc was not novel to us. A two horse driven carriage was specially kept aside for our use. We were familiar with the protocol to be followed in the State too from the early childhood.


 

Shri Keshavlal Oza in a state carriage. Photo: Oza Family Archives

K.K.Oza, the Diwan of the State of Vallabhipur 5th from right. Photo: Oza Family Archives


State Band of Princely State. Photo: Oza Family Archives




Unfortunately there is always some conflict among the royal families. Thakore Saheb’s uncle began interfering and wanted changes in some of the decisions taken by Bapuji, his younger brothers too started interfering. When such a situation developed around 1936, two incidents happened. The Diwan of Bhavnagar Shri Prabhakar Patni while passing through the railway station of Lathi called Bapuji and told him that if he would agree to become the revenue commissioner of the State of Bhavnagar, he would speak with the Maharaj Saheb of Bhavnagar. Bapuji agreed. Shri Patani promised to write back on reaching Bhavnagar. But Shri Patni passed away of heart failure immediately on reaching Bhavnagar and this matter ended there. However Bapuji was not disturbed due to this unfortunate development-this being one of the main qualities of his life.

 

Shri Prabhakar Patni, Diwan of Bhavnagar, Photo: Wikipedia

Maharaja of Bhavnagar, Krishnakumar Singh Ji, Photo: Indian Rajputs website


The second incident was that at that time, the people of the States of Mansa and Rajkot (details of Rajkot Satyagraha) were on satyagraha (struggle for truth) against the State. The farmers and people of these two states under the leadership of Sardar Patel were on Satyagraha (movement) on the issues of high land/farm/revenue taxes collected by the State. 

 

Image of Mansa and Rajkot Satyagraha where people are behind bars. Photo: 
https://opinionmagazine.co.uk/gandhiji-ane-rajkot-satyagraha/


Public meeting in Rajkot Satyagraha. Photo: 
https://opinionmagazine.co.uk/gandhiji-ane-rajkot-satyagraha/

Mansa’s Thakore Saheb was the son in law of Wakaner Thakore Saheb. At that time, the Diwan of Mansa, Shri Girdharbhai had tried to repress severely the satyagrahis (participants in the Satyagraha) and the public meetings and demonstrations of the satyagrahis were lathi charged (canned). One of their senior leaders Gopalbhai Patel too was injured in the lathi charge. The daughter of Wakaner immediately requested the Wakaner State to control the situation. Girdharbhai was asked to leave immediately and Bapuji was called upon by the Wakaner Thakore Saheb to take over the administration of Mansa right away.

 

Bapuji too was keen to leave Lathi. The Lathi Thakore Saheb accepted Bapuji’s resignation unwillingly. The eminent people, farmers of Lathi when we left for Mansa, gave us a big farewell. We reached Mansa at 10 am the next morning. Mansa was as big as a city but it did not have a railway station. There was a railway station ten miles away at Makakhad. The State police had come to receive us at the Station with the State car. We followed the police escort as we entered Mansa through its main gate. I was very eager to see the new town. However all the shops on the main road and the bazaar were closed. We learnt later that the people had called ‘bandh’ (closure) in protest against the appointment of Bapuji and wanted him to know the strength and unity of the people in their struggle against the State.

 

That same evening Bapuji invited the leaders of the movement for a meeting in the porch of our new home. Gopal Patel who was injured in the lathi charge too was present. In no time the debate turned aggressive and the people declared that if the repression continued, Raolji (Thakore Saheb) would have to leave the State…….., etc etc…...I was sitting and listening to all this. It was the first time that I experienced Bapuji being threatened so openly by the people and a total close down of a town in protest of his appointment.  

In spite of the tense atmosphere, Bapuji calmly proceeded with the introduction and the meeting. He expressed sincere concern and regret towards those injured. He also assured everyone that there will no longer be any repression in the town or villages and that he had already instructed the police department accordingly. This he said is necessary because without goodwill between the people and the State, it was not possible to run a State. He also assured that the State would accept the reasonable demands of the people. He also told the people that mounted police had been withdrawn. He also expressed faith in the people that they too would not wish anything that would go against the interest of the State. At the same time he firmly asserted that he would never allow anything that would adversely affect the State. He insisted that differences could be resolved with discussions, and that he has been appointed by the Wakaner and Lathi Thakore Sahebs to see that the Satyagraha is withdrawn.

 

It is important to emphasize here that no sooner was bapuji appointed the Diwan of Mansa that all the newspapers of Gujarat highlighted this news extensively and prominently. Newspapers all over Gujarat carried headlines like ‘ Mansa on fire handed over to Oza?’ Bapuji immediately started the process of arbitration towards an amicable solution. It was at this time that Sardar Patel called for Bapuji. Bapuji himself wanted Sardar Patel to intervene in the matter and proceeded to Ahmedabad. It was later that Bapuji narrated this incident to us, ‘During the discussion with Sardar, he immediately threatened me and said- Keshavlal are you aware that I could crush Mansa with my two fingers and in no time?’ In reply Bapuji said sweetly but firmly, ‘Yes, I have no doubt in the matter; however, Mansa is a very small State. If you could crush the State of Baroda, then that would be something worthy of credit.’ An extremely intelligent Sardar instead of getting angry, laughed/smiled and said, “Keshavlal, so you do dare say this to me!’ Without getting annoyed, Sardar intervened and the Satyagraha at Mansa was withdrawn within six months.

 

Darbargadh Palace, Mansa, Photo: Bhole and Associates

Though Mansa was a small State, the satyagraha here made it a renowned place all over the country, especially in Gujarat and along with it, Bapujni became a well-known figure and was appreciated as an extremely efficient administrator. I have been personally a witness to the accolades showered upon Bapuji for his intelligence, honesty, simple nature, commitment, etc. These qualities of his were reported in the newspapers frequently. But ultimately the disputes within the Royal family of Mansa was the reason why Bapuji left after five years of service and moved to Wakaner where he was made officer on special duty till he was summoned by the State of Lakhtar and ultimately became the Diwan of Vallabhipur. He remained in Vallabhipur till all the States were unified after independence.

 

The Maharaja of Jaipur taking the oath of allegiance, 1948. Photo by Kulwant Roy (1914-1984) and photo credit : Indian Express and Aditya Arya Archives, Chairman & Trustee, India Photo Archive Foundation.

 

Two incidents during this period are worth mentioning here. At that time, Gohilwad of Saurashtra constituted of the State of Bhavnagar, Vala, Palitana and the Lathi States. At that time, Kathiawad assembly used to be organized under the leadership of Balvantbhai Mehta. As the State of Bhavnagar was strict with these congress activists, the congress workers had Vala as their head quarters. Due to the people’s struggle under the leadership of Gandhi, the British Empire became weak   and it became clear that the days of British Raj were numbered.

 

Balvant Mehta who later became the Chief Minister of Gujarat State

This incident is of the year 1945-46. The congress president of the time Shri Uchharangrai Dhebar summoned Bapuji to meet him at Dhola railway junction. Bapuji was aware that the days of the State too were numbered and if a person like Dhebarbhai summoned him, he as the representative of the State should meet him. Bapuji met Dhebarbhai. In the first class compartment of the train Dhebarbhai was traveling in, he was accompanied by one of the leading businessman of the region Mr Mohan Moti. It was the wish of Dhebarbhai that Vala State which earned its revenue mainly from the wheat crop, contribute 2000 maan of wheat (1 maan =20 kgs ) at Rs 8 per maan to the Saurashtra development samiti (organization). This wheat was to be distributed to the poor by the samiti at a lower price as the market price of the wheat was Rs 16 a maan at the time. Bapuji accepted the demand of Dhebarbhai immediately even without consulting the Thakore Saheb of Vala and agreed to give 2000 maan of wheat to the Samiti (organization). But at the same time Dhebarbhai placed one more demand before Bapuji, he asked Bapuji to give 2000 maan of wheat to the trader Mohan Moti at the same rate of Rs 8/- a maan. Bapuji refused to accept this demand. Dhebarbhai in retaliation accused the State of Vala of black-marketing of wheat.  Bapuji refuted this false allegation. Dhebarbhai also gave a veiled threat to Bapuji and said, ‘it seems you do not fully understand the implication of your refusal to give wheat.’ Bapuji replied calmly, ‘I know that within a year or so you will become the Chief Minister of the Government of Saurashtra, and at that time if the new Government of Saurashtra deems fit to employ me in its service, I will serve the Government with the same loyalty as I am serving the State now.” (Dheberbhai indeed became the Chief Minister of Saurashtra which saw many public protests under him. For details click here.  



Shri U.N.Dhebar, President, All India Congress Party greeting Mr. Nobusuke Kishi the Japanese Prime Minister at the Banquet held in the latter’s honor by the Prime Minister of India, at Rashtrapati Bhavan, New Delhi on May 23, 1957. Source of caption and photo: http://photodivision.gov.in/IntroPhotodetails.asp?thisPage=1244


 

The matter was soon forgotten. The British left and India became independent in 1947. All the princely States of Saurashtra were unified as one democratic State of Saurashtra. The administration of Vala was handed over to the Government of Saurashtra and Bapuji became the employee of the Government of Saurashtra. He was responsible for the administration of Muli and Sayla States till the process of their unification was completed with the State of Saurashtra.

 

Before Bapuji handed over his responsibilities at Vallabhipur, Vala Thakore Saheb told him to change the entries in the book to show that he was drawing a salary of Rs 700/- for the previous two years because otherwise, he would be given that kind of job that would only commensurate with his salary. He also said that this was the practice adopted by the States such as Bilkha, Manavadar, Vadia, etc. But Bapuji refused to do so. At that time Bapuji had only about 3-4 years of service left before retirement in 1953. Loyalty and honesty were the two basic qualities with which he served and handled the administration of all States all his life.

 

But soon the refusal to give 2000 maan of wheat to Mohan Moti on the insistence of Dhebarbhai began to have its adverse implications on Bapuji. His position as Diwan was deliberately ignored, moreover his excellent performance in resolving the serious issues of the State of Mansa too was overlooked and he was not given the post of a collector though he was entitled for the same. He was instead made deputy collector at Surendranagar, giving the excuse of the low salary he was drawing at Vallabhipur.  Shri Bholanathbhai Thakore, the chief magistrate of Wadhvan on having been treated in the same way, filed a case and won. The Government had to pay damages worth Rs 18,000/- to him on court order. But Bapuji refused to pursue this course of action against the injustice meted out to him.

 

That the so called congress leaders were actually so revengeful is clear from the fact that Bapuji was also deprived of his pension on the grounds that his service in the State of Mansa was a break from his continues service in Saurashtra and therefore not entitled to any pension (Mansa was not a part of Saurashtra but was in Gujarat and so it was considered that bapuji had a break of service from Saurashtra!). In spite of having served all the States honestly and continually without a break, his pension was not sanctioned. This was the result for having refused to black market wheat. Bapuji retired in 1953 and passed away in the year 1986 – he was deprived of his rightful pension for 33 years! And yet, he never thought of going to Court against the State though Bholanathbhai had the same problem and had got a court order in his favor.

 

There is another incident of the vengeance and appalling behavior of the Khadi clad, white-capped congressmen.  During the vacation of 1945-46, I had come to Vallibhipur from Ahmedabad during vacation. One evening there was a public meeting to be held in Vala and the congress leaders were to speak about the exploitation of the people and misadministration by the States. It is important to disclose here that one day I saw Bapuji engrossed in some deep thought. On seeing him in such a thoughtful mood, I asked him if anything was wrong. He said, “ Thakore saheb is insisting on buying the Humber car. This is a very expensive car costing 16 to 17 thousand rupees where as hilman of the same company is cheaper and costing Rs 5500/-.” Bapuji knew the congressmen for years and was aware that no sooner would Thakore Saheb buy this car that there would be protest rallies, demonstrations, etc. And yet due to Thakore Saheb’s insistence, an order for Humber had to be placed.

 

   I was present at the public meeting mentioned above and actually there were protest speeches against the purchase of such an expensive car. In fact, one of the congressmen went to the extent of saying that those Diwans who advise the Kings to live in luxury at the cost of poor people should be hanged. However, soon I learnt about the dishonesty of these congressmen themselves. The congress leaders had organized this meeting in order to get a contract of road building from the State and for no other reason.

 

Further, once the State of Saurashtra was unified and Shri Rasiklal Parikh became the chief minister of Saurashtra, Bapuji had gone to meet him to resolve some matters concerning Vallabhipur ( Bapuji had been appointed by the Thakore Saheb as his life time advisor.) When Bapuji entered the CMs bungalow, he saw a brand new limousine imported from the USA parked there.   On further inquiry, Bapuji learnt that three Limousines had been imported for three ministers.  I was very saddened to see that the actions and words of the congressmen did not match at all. After independence, Gandhiji himself had advised dissolution of the Congress.

 

Rasiklal Parikh, Photo: Entrance India

One example of Bapuji’s selfless, honest and simple life is worth mentioning here. As the Diwan (chief administrator) of Vala he went to the office in a carriage driven by two horses and all along the route people would greet him. He was in a position of power all his life but on the day the States were unified and when he returned to Vala after retirement he did not hesitate even for a minute to go buy vegetables as an ordinary person. Simplicity, Loyalty and honesty are the three qualities that we all brothers and sisters have learnt from him and this is why we have been able to lead our lives happily."


Savitri Keshavlal Oza. Photo: Oza Family Archives

About my Grandmother, my father, K.K.Oza says the following: "My mother too had completed matriculation in the year 1924. She was very knowledgeable in Sanskrit and had the whole of Geeta by heart. She could also interpret the Gitaji well. She left no stone unturned to see that all of us get the best of education and move ahead in life. This is why my younger brother became an MD in the year 1955 (Dr.M.K.Oza was among the first cardiologists our city of Bhavnagar had), second brother (D.K.Oza) cleared IAS (He rose to become the Chief Election Commissioner in the State of Tamil Nadu and was also the Vice Chancellor of Gandhi Gram University in Tamil Nadu), the third after having successfully attempted many examinations, decided to become a professor (of Economics at M.S. Univesity, Vadodara) as per his liking. I too (K.K.Oza) was sent to England to become a Barrister (My father became the general manager of one of the leading nationalized banks of Gujarat, the State Bank of Saurashtra and was instrumental in seeing that banking facilities reach the marginalized sections of the society). Baring my older sister, my other two sisters are postgraduates."




Nalini Nayar, taught in Kenya and Canada. Photo: Oza Family Archives


Matu Oza in the center being sent to England for further study in medecine in the 1950s, R-L- C.M. Trivedi - public prosecutor Mumbai High Court, H.M.Trivedi, once a Minister of Shipping and transportation, Government of India, Kokila Dave also a post graduate, Dr. Jyotibe. On Trivedi, once the Vice Chancellor of SNDT University, K.K.Oza and Savitri Oza, Balaben C. Trivedi, my grand aunt. Photo: Trivedi Family Archives



Kanu Oza (right) sailing to England in early 1950s to study law. Photo: Oza Family Archives.


The role and inclination for good education on my maternal side family too had an important influence on us as far as our education is concerned. Both my mamas were barristers and my masi became a graduate when very few women in Gujarat studied at all. She also went to London University for further studies.  My older masi was an eminent social worker and very well respected in Rajkot.



Dadima, Narmadaben Mulshanker Trivedi, my great godmother, the first feminist I know. Photo: Trivedi Family Archives

 

Nani Mashi, my grand aunt was sent to England by my great grand mother Narmadaben when anyone crossing the seas was excommunicated from the communities they belonged to. Photo: Trivedi Family Archives.

Dadima ( Narmada Mulshanker Trivedi) and both my mamas (H.M. Trivedi-Hariprasad and C.M. Trivedi- Chandrakant. H M. Trivedi was the minister of shipping and transport, Government of India and C.M. Trivedi, a public prosecutor and one of the famous cases he handled was that of Kawas Nanavati. For more about the case, click here. Film Rustom is based on this case. ) were very fond of all of us and so the children of the entire family could study in the Ahmedabad house, which was kept open forever for everyone to stay and study. We could study without much expenditure because of this and all of us could pursue higher studies. My mami’s (Dr Jyotiben Trivedi) contribution too is very valuable in this matter. Doctor by profession, she also became the vice chancellor of SNDYT university. Naturally, she was an inspiration to the rest of us. Mama and Mami’s contribution in Devendra clearing IAS is also very significant.

 

 In short, our family has been very educated and all family members have either been judges, doctors, professors, engineers, diwans, vice chancellors, economists, and in the generation after us, there are two daughters who have even taken up social service.

 

After retirement, Bapuji served Anand Ashram Bilkha as the chief administrator for 33 years. He stayed in the ashram for 20 years. My mother too spent all these years with him in the Ashram. Bapuji reopened the Sanskrit Pathshala once again and today there are 29 students studying here.

 

 

Bapuji (Keshavlal.K.Oza) passed away at the age of 91 without suffering any illness on 8th of April 1986 at Anand Ashram, Bilkha at 7.30 in the evening. His wish to die within the premises of Gurudev came true due to his deep faith and service of Gurudev. Press trust of India had officially announced the news of Bapuji’s passing away and therefore carried by all the newspapers of Gujarat. Ahmedabad and Baroda All India Radio too had announced in their news bulletin the passing away of Bapuji. " K. K. Oza


I reproduce the family history here as it is interwoven with the political history of Saurashtra and Gujarat.